Vintage clothing often feels like reconnecting with the past, discovering unmatched gems and pieces that are simply not found at regular retail stores. Vintage items are little pieces of history that add depth and a level of uniqueness to your wardrobe or home. Our vintage shopping guide series highlights the best vintage stores by city for clothing, accessories, home goods, furniture and more.
What Goes Around Comes Around
Specializing in luxury finds, What Goes Around features designer vintage pieces both in-store and online. Popular amongst the Instagram set, each drop is eagerly anticipated. Points for an easy-to-navigate site and the luxurious feel of their store interior.
48 Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937
Antiques Center South Hampton
A curated selection of furniture, artwork, lighting and other interior design items can be found at Antiques Center South Hampton. Stop here for vintage furniture, fixtures and decor as well as statement jewelry and accessories, including Early American and English furniture, and Nippon Porcelain pottery.
245 County Rd 39, Southampton, NY 11968
Barbara Trujillo Antiques
This destination is vintage jewelry heaven, set with all sorts of treasures from luxury baubles to unique costume jewelry. Barbara Trujillo Antiques the perfect place to spend an afternoon pouring through their extensive inventory, and they’re known to boast everything from turquoise and silver pieces to vintage Chanel bling.
2466 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
Deep Blue Vintage
Everything at Deep Blue Vintage fall within 1890 to 1990. Located at the Montauk Hotel, this vintage outpost offers “tightly curated collections of apparel” from antique to yesteryear, as well as a selection of reworked denim pieces and a thorough collection of vintage Levis.
88 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY
Melet Mercantile Outpost
*temporarily closed until further notice
This seasonal Montauk spot was founded by Bob Melet, former director of vintage buying for Ralph Lauren’s Double RL label. Melet Mercantile Montauk Outpost is stocked with rare finds that are curated by Melet himself from destinations all over the world, not only garments, but also vinyl records, books and art prints.
102 Industrial Rd, Montauk, NY 11954
North See Vintage
Created by Frank Cassata Designs and Kevin Calica, North See Vintage is stocked full of American collectibles, home furnishings and international textiles. Their aesthetic combines Americana with eclectic touch for a collection of inspired prints, textiles, decor and furnishings.
675 N Sea Rd Southampton, NY 11968
Bohemian with a touch of down-to-earth luxury, WYLD Blue carries items that meet at the intersection of wabi sabi, boho chic, glam and luxury. Curated to the core, owner Saha Benz keeps offerings well stocked with women’s and children’s clothing as well as unique accessories and homewares. Seasonally located in Montauk during summer, and Aspen during winter.
716 Montauk Hwy, Store 2, Level 2 | 210 S Galena St, Aspen, CO 81611
Come to MONC XIII for timeless inspiration. Filled with pieces dating through the 18th century to modern day, there is something here for every MCM lover. A combination of vintage, antique and current styles of furniture, interior decor and table-top items can be bought in-store or online. MONC XIII is run by former interior designer Natasha Esch and her husband Matt Coffin.
40 Madison St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
ARF Thrift and Treasure
ARF Thrift and Treasure is stocked with vintage clothing, paintings, houseware, furniture and even cars. Each spring ARF Thrift opens the South Fork high season with a cocktail benefit, inviting interior designers to curate the entire interior as a show house with themed rooms. Feel great about each purchase knowing all proceeds go towards the cats and dogs awaiting adoption with Animal Rescue Fund of the Hamptons.
17 Poxabogue Ln, Sagaponack, NY 11962
Black Swan Antiques
A midcentury lover’s haven, this shop is like walking into a turn of the century time traveler’s house, complete with antique navajo rugs, leather sofas and unique glass pieces. Black Swan is a Sag Harbor treasure trove that can be shopped IRL, or online via 1st Dibs.
26 Main Street Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Fishers Home Furnishings
A family run, 35 year old business, Fishers boasts a curation of airy, beachy furnishings. Visit their Sag Harbor location for upholstery, furniture, textiles, home decor and custom-built furniture. They often have storewide sales on their beautiful items so keep an eye out.
144 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963
Wyeth sells a beautiful array of mid-century modern furniture inspired by vintage design, as well as an original in-house furniture line. One-of-a-kind chairs, coffee tables, lamps, and tableware can all be rented out for temporary stays, creative jobs and special projects.
3654 Montauk Hwy, Sagaponack, NY 11962
LVIS Clothing Shops | Bargain Box Thrift
LVIS (The Ladies’ Village Improvement Society of East Hampton) offers not only men’s and women’s fashion but also furniture, housewares and a bookstore full of fiction, non-fiction, art, photography and local books. The revenue that the shops provide goes towards funding for LVIS initiatives like scholarship offerings, notably their Madelon DeVoe Scholarship is for adult women currently enrolled or planning to enroll in college.
95 Main St, East Hampton, NY